Dutch disease in the bolivarian republic of venezuela hrcak srce. By the 1930s, an economic doctor would diagnose some dutch disease. In many countries, natural resources have been detrimental to the economic development. In fact, venezuelas stagnation in the wake of the previous oil price hikes of the 1970s qualifies it. As of 2011, venezuela is the country with the worlds highest proven oil reserves. The political and economic situation of venezuela has been dominating world media for quite some time now. The monetary and fiscal history of venezuela 19602016. The deceleration of currency appreciation is an easier and more viable strategy to prevent the adverse effects of dutch disease. Oil wealth and the resource curse in venezuela international.
Examining the dutch disease in twospeed economies pdf. The dutch disease to further complicate matters, venezuela is plagued by the dutch disease an economic phenomenon associated with the resource curse. The puzzle, then, is not really one of how the negative effects of dutch disease can be reduced. Sep 12, 2018 however, similar with most oilexporting countries, venezuela had infrastructures and capabilities that favored oil production and exportation. This economic disease is caught whenever a commodity brings a sudden increase of income in one sector of the economy, which is not matched by increased income in other sectors of the economy. The traditional explanation for the resource curse is the dutch disease or deindustrialization. To start, lets examine the symptoms of the disease.
Dutch disease is an economic phenomenon that affects countries. The threat is currently greatest in venezuela and bolivia. Dutch disease and venezuelan economics in retrospective. In the netherlands, nigeria, venezuela and elsewhere, oil has pushed out other sectors, in this case dairy, cocoa beans, coffee and. This paper integrates the existing dutch disease models of an oil boom into a reducedform threesector model and estimates it for five developing oilexporting countries having significant agricultural and manufacturing sectors.
Perhaps the most evident effect oil has had on venezuelas economy is the appearance of the dutch disease. By 1929, the dramatic development of the venezuela oil industry had begun to dominate all other economic sectors in the country, however, agricultural production began to decrease dramatically. Aid, dutch disease, and manufacturing growth forthcoming in the journal of development economics raghuram g. Countries whose economies depend on a single commodity prone to wild price fluctuations as is oil are notoriously poor at long term planning. Dutch disease is an economics term that refers to the negative consequences arising from large increases in the value of a countrys currency. The term was coined by the economist in 1977, but what does it mean. Jul 26, 2019 the authors describe how venezuela was afflicted with the dutch disease, a disease that also afflicted mexico with the same commodity, oil, during the presidency of jose lopez portillo in the early 1980s. Guyana, a country of about 780,000 which shares a border with brazil, suriname and venezuela in the northeast of south america, will see economic. However, venezuela began to face economic difficulties due to chavezs populist policies and on 2 june 2010, he declared an economic war. Pdf analysis of dutch disease phenomenon in case of venezuela. Congenital heart disease is a large, rapidly emerging global problem in child health. Dutch disease is a concept that describes an economic phenomenon where the rapid development of one sector of the economy particularly natural resources precipitates a decline in other sectors. Thanks to fracking technology, which has enabled a shale revolution, the united states has become one of the worlds largest producers of oil.
Dutch exports of goods and services, 196097 % of gdp source. Much has been written about the resource curse, yet there are many misconceptions about the mechanisms underlying the. Venezuela essentially suffered from dutch disease because the chavez administration focused primarily on its oil industry while it neglected its manufacturing and agriculture sectors. As in venezuela and saudi arabia, the dutch disease that an economy catches comes from too much dependence for revenue and jobs on one commodity like oil. It has surpassed countries such as saudi arabia and iran. Oecd reports on netherlands, various issues 1 according to the handbook of development economics the dutch disease is defined as.
Venezuela s descent into economic and political chaos in recent years is a cautionary tale of the. Venezuela institute for health metrics and evaluation. The economist explains what dutch disease is, and why its bad. Our story starts in 1922 when oil was discovered in venezuela. The imf thinks this country will see growth of 86%. When the raw materials run out, the economy can be in a worse position than before. The term originated in holland after the discovery of north sea gas. He used the phrase dutch disease to refer to foreign currency inflows that keep the currency stronger than it should be, reducing the competitiveness of domestic enterprises, thereby boosting imports and hurting exports. Understanding venezuelas crisis dutch diseases, money doctors, and magicians by daniel hellinger fernando coronil the magical state. In academic circles its called dutch disease, a term that was coined after the netherlands suffered a decline in manufacturing. Pdf dutch disease and venezuelan economics in retrospective. The monetary and fiscal history of venezuela 19602016y diego restuccia university of toronto and nber july 2018.
The dutch disease is a countrys chronic exchange rate overvaluation caused. Venezuela suffered from dutch disease, the process whereby extraordinary foreign currency earnings from exports of natural resources lead a government to increase the monetary sup. In the model, there is a nontradable sector which includes services and two tradable sectors. It is primarily associated with a natural resource.
Venezuelas descent into economic and political chaos in recent years is a cautionary tale of the. Mar 07, 2017 venezuela the country with the largest oil reserves is facing a food shortage today. A commodity boom stretches the production possibility frontier rightward h. The political, economic, human rights, and humanitarian crises in venezuela combine to compel venezuelans to leave and make them unable or unwilling to return. The value of the exchange rate and the dutch disease scielo. But contrary to some theories, such as that of dutch disease, oil is not the problem of the venezuelan economy, the problem lies in how the vast amounts of resources generated from oil were utilized. When the raw materials run out, the economy can be in a worse position than.
Jun 18, 2018 an astute observer of the indian economy asked me this question a few months back. The imf thinks this country will see growth of 86% in. Venezuela crisis explained short documentary 2017 youtube. Venezuela is taken as an example for further analysis of dutch disease symptoms.
The dutch disease is a major market failure originated in the existence of cheap and abundant natural. Edgardo lander over the 15 years of the bolivarian government in venezuela, significant changes have taken place in the political culture, the social and organisational fabric, and the material living conditions of previously excluded lowincome groups. That is, revenue from natural resources hurts traditional manufacturing through an increase in the exchange rate. While the discovery of oil in guyana is a huge development, director of oil and gas services with uk based company ernst and young ey global, chris patemanjones, warned against the dutch disease.
Venezuela, led by nicolas maduro, does not have enough money to provide even the most basic services such as healthcare. Devaluation in small open economies the salterswan ntgs. This represents a strain of whats called dutch disease. Venezuela is a country situated in the north of south. Nigeria, indonesia, venezuela and mexico are examples of.
Illustrating stories from around the world in 3 minutes. Prior to oil the coffee industry had been the main export in venezuela. Seven years later, their production was second only to the u. In economics, the dutch disease is the apparent causal relationship between the increase in. The deindustrialization of a nations economy that occurs when the discovery of a natural resource raises the value of that nations currency, making manufactured goods less competitive with other nations, increasing imports and decreasing exports. However, similar with most oilexporting countries, venezuela had infrastructures and capabilities that favored oil production and exportation. Pdf workers remittances and dutch disease in bangladesh. How venezuelas oil created an incurable case of dutch disease. Dutch disease arises when a natural resource windfall generates a sudden. Dutch disease definition, disadvantages, and how to avoid. An astute observer of the indian economy asked me this question a few months back. Global, regional, and national burden of congenital heart disease, 19902017. Dutch disease, resource curse, petrostate but at root the logic is simple enough.
Rather, given that a reasonable understanding of the economic problem. The classic economic model describing dutch disease was developed by the economists w. What makes venezuelas repetition infernal is that each time it. Apr 18, 2016 this represents a strain of whats called dutch disease. Petrostates are thought to be vulnerable to what economists call dutch disease pdf. Jan 14, 2018 the dutch disease refers to the problems associated with a rapid increase in the production of raw materials like oil and gas causing a decline in other sectors of the economy. The dutch disease refers to the problems associated with a rapid increase in the production of raw materials like oil and gas causing a decline in other sectors of the economy. He used the phrase dutch disease to refer to foreign currency inflows that keep the currency stronger than it should be, reducing the competitiveness of domestic enterprises, thereby. Without the ability to substantially alter the prevalence of congenital heart disease, interventions and.
Rajan and arvind subramanian december 2009 we examine the effects of aid on the growth of manufacturing, using a methodology that exploits the variation within countries and across manufacturing sectors, and corrects for. If venezuela had succumbed to dutch disease, we would expect petroleum exports to dominate the countrys growth in real gdp across the 2003 to 2008 period. Venezuela the country with the largest oil reserves is facing a food shortage today. Nov 04, 2019 guyana, a country of about 780,000 which shares a border with brazil, suriname and venezuela in the northeast of south america, will see economic growth of 86% in 2020, according to the imf. The two primary strategies that can help solve dutch disease are listed below. Jan 24, 2019 venezuelas descent into economic and political chaos in recent years is a cautionary tale of the. Author develops simplified graphical model of dutch disease and examines economics performance of venezuela in a retrospective on the. The rise and fall of a petrostate council on foreign.
The economics, culture, and politics of oil in venezuela. The deindustrialization of a nations economy that occurs. Jul 03, 2019 dutch disease is an economics term that refers to the negative consequences arising from large increases in the value of a countrys currency. A detailed analysis by westin 2004, based on data through 2003, concluded that, despite the existence of some dutch disease symptoms, russia had not contracted the fullblown disease by end2003. Edgardo lander over the 15 years of the bolivarian government in venezuela, significant changes have taken place in the political culture, the social and organisational fabric, and the material living conditions of. We will argue that the main explanation behind such a dramatic shift in economic development is the phenomenon of the resource curse or dutch disease. Inflation and hyperinflation in venezuela 1970s2016 a post. The putative mechanism is that as revenues increase in the growing sector or inflows of foreign aid, the given nations currency becomes stronger. Author develops simplified graphical model of dutch disease and examines economics performance of venezuela in a retrospective on the basis of most recent open statistical data despite the. In fact, venezuelas stagnation in the wake of the previous oil price hikes of the 1970s qualifies it as a classic victim of this disease. The symptoms of the dutch disease are observed in the prolonged currency overvaluation during the high oil revenue periods. Dutch disease in the bolivarian republic of venezuela. The overwhelming presence of oil did act, indirectly, to deform the economy and national. Pdf on mar 15, 2010, kishore g kulkarni and others published analysis of dutch disease phenomenon in case of venezuela find, read.
The social works initiated by chavezs government relied on oil products, the keystone of the venezuelan economy, leading to dutch disease according to javier corrales. The oil and gas expert made these comments on monday during a presentation hosted by the ministry of natural resources. Venezuelas problem is the crashing price of oil, its major export commodity. But now, as the united states celebrates an oil boom of its own, the question must be asked. Petrostates are thought to be vulnerable to what economists call dutch disease pdf, a term coined during the 1970s after the netherlands. The dutch disease is a resource reallocation process away from less pro. The economist explains what dutch disease is, and why its. Similarly, roland 2005 argued that it is premature to conclude that the russian economy is experiencing dutch disease.
In economics, the dutch disease is the apparent causal relationship between the increase in the economic development of a specific sector for example natural resources and a decline in other sectors like the manufacturing sector or agriculture. Informed diagnoses for prudent prognoses prepared by mwanza nkusu1 authorized for distribution by menachem katz march 2004 abstract this working paper should not be reported as representing the views of the imf. The dutch disease in saudi arabia and venezuela elaine schwartz february 12, 2016. We argue that the root cause of the precarious economic situation in venezuela lies in the long term failure to implement structural changes, ensuring industrial diversification and lessening the dependency on oil exports. Timeseries annual data for the period 19661986 are used for algeria, ecuador, indonesia, nigeria and venezuela. It accounted for 12% of gdp in 2009 and has colossal socioeconomic implications for the country. Santos journalofdevelopmenteconomics22018102114 her. But unable to manage it alone, venezuela depended on standard oil, gulf, and royal dutch. A large increase in natural resource revenues can hurt other sectors of the economy, particularly exportbased manufacturing, by causing inflation or exchange rate appreciation and shifting labor and capital from the nonresource sector to the resource sector see revenue management reader. The monetary and fiscal history of venezuela 19602016y diego restuccia university of toronto and nber july 2018 abstract i document the salient features of monetary and scal outcomes for the venezuelan economy during the 1960 to 2016 period.
288 1520 489 134 1371 949 639 801 1191 294 692 686 489 912 1211 894 953 1309 598 1501 123 700 704 238 65 229 53 221 622 422 1169 561 637 1413 329 747 1034 175 1171 744